Hello dear
Welcome To Evelyn's Kitchen
Evelyn's Kitchen is a cherished culinary gem nestled at 2317 1st Ave, New York, NY. Renowned for its homemade Thanksgiving and holiday catering, the kitchen's delicious offerings are crafted with care and heart. Customers rave about the juicy turkey, rich cornbread stuffing, and decadent sweet potato soufflé, which evokes the warmth of home cooking. With exceptional service, Evelyn's Kitchen is celebrated for accommodating last-minute events and delivering beautifully packaged meals ready for reheating. The rave reviews reflect not just great food, but the joy of togetherness, making every holiday truly special. Discover the magic of Evelyn’s Kitchen!
About
Evelyn's Kitchen
Welcome to Evelyn's Kitchen, a culinary haven nestled in the heart of New York City at 2317 1st Ave, New York, NY 10035. This charming storefront has made a name for itself with its spectacular homemade dishes and impeccable catering services, capturing the hearts of locals and visitors alike.
What sets Evelyn's Kitchen apart is not just its exceptional dishes but the passion and care that goes into every recipe. As highlighted by loyal customer Ilana Nunn Okafor, their Thanksgiving menu is legendary. From the juicy, flavorful turkey to the chef's-kiss cornbread stuffing, each dish resonates with warmth and heart. The sweet potato souffle is described as a savory dessert, while the brussels sprouts perfectly balance bitterness with honey's sweetness. And let's not overlook the crowd-pleaser, the barbecue short rib, which everyone craves. This menu isn't just a meal; it’s a celebration of togetherness during the holidays.
Beyond the holidays, Evelyn's Kitchen also shines when it comes to event catering. Jennifer Han had a last-minute birthday party that required flexibility and creativity. The team at Evelyn's Kitchen not only met her needs but exceeded expectations with their punctuality and delicious food options. Guests were enamored, eager to know where the delectable spread came from. This level of service exemplifies their commitment to making every occasion memorable.
The love for food at Evelyn’s Kitchen transcends mere eating; it becomes a treasured experience. For those who missed family gatherings, like Camara Price, the catered meals can soothe homesickness, offering a taste of comfort and nostalgia. The thoughtful packaging for easy reheating ensures that every bite maintains its flavor and warmth, making it perfect for any situation, big or small.
As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I can't recommend Evelyn's Kitchen enough. Whether you're celebrating a holiday or hosting an intimate gathering, their food brings people together, curating an experience that is both heartwarming and memorable. If you’re in the area or searching for a reliable caterer, make sure to place your order. After one delightful bite, you will be thanking yourself for a delicious decision.
For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at +1 646-476-7906.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ The Thanksgiving menu at Evelyn's Kitchen (EK) is, by far, the finest Thanksgiving one can choose! Everything tastes homemade and is made with the utmost care. For almost 10 years, we have repeatedly had EK for Thanksgiving and Christmas. The turkey is juicy and flavor is delicious; the cornbread stuffing is...chef's kiss; the sweet potato souffle is practically like eating a savory dessert; the brussels sprouts balance the bitterness of the green with the sweetness of honey. On top of that, we always have the bbq short rib because EVERYONE loves that unexpected add. Desserts are always an added treat and we always opt for the pecan pie bars. The meal is packaged is re-heatable containers for the oven and in insulated bags that travel well. Order it now, thank me later. You're welcome. ”
“ Hosted a private birthday party for my partner last minute (under a week), and Evelyn's Kitchen went above and beyond to help come up with a menu, accommodate my budget, all within less than a week's time, and was flexible to adjust for a fluctuating # of guests all throughout the week! They helped come set up and lay out the food, were timely and punctual and communicative, and all my guests loved the food and kept asking where we got catering! Would highly recommend for anyone throwing an event, large or small! ”
“ We had Evelyn's Kitchen cater our Thanksgiving feast and everything was delicious! The sweet potatoes were out of this world and the whole family kept saying how great everything was. Ayala delivered everything with easy to follow instructions the night before. It was perfect. Highly recommend! ”
“ Ordered christmas dinner for local delivery. Food came exactly when they said, and with easy to follow instructions for re-heating. The whole family loved it! ”
“ I wasn't able to be with my family this holiday and ordered Christmas dinner from Evelyn's Kitchen. Every course was fantastic and cured a bit of homesickness I had. Thank you for all of your hard work. It was an amazing meal. ”
“ Evelyn’s Kitchen is fantastic. The food is superb ( I had the cornbread stuffing and short ribs). The customer service and attention to detail is unbelievable. This was my first time trying Evelyn’s Kitchen and I will be a recurring customer. ”
“ Visited on a Friday after having dinner a couple blocks away on a whim. Me and my partner bought the triple chocolate brownie, devil dog pudgie, and smores pudgie. Over all SOOO GOOD!!! Service was really friendly and atmosphere was homey. I recommend this if you’re near East Harlem. ”
“ Amazing Thanksgiving Dinner courtesy of EK! Was perfect since we have a newborn and no time to cook. This was our first time ordering the holiday meal and EK did not disappoint - even my very picky mom had several servings Portions were generous and food as ready for pickup right on time. Even the packaging was top tier! Will be ordering again for all the holidays! ”